Pain has a palette.
An expert explained why many trauma survivors struggle to make their homes their own.
“As a therapist, I’ve noticed that people who didn’t have an upbringing where they could develop a full sense of self don’t really know how to decorate their own house,” clinical psychologist Vincent Barbieri told The Post.
And, according to Barbieri, that uncertainty can lead to uninspired purchases — or decision paralysis — that ultimately fail to bring joy.
“You can get the plain brown sofa and buy all of your sh-t from Costco, but I guarantee it’s going to be a different feeling walking into that house than walking into one that truly reflects things that make you happy,” he said.
So how do you go from cookie-cutter surroundings to a home that genuinely feels like you?
Barbieri says many of his patients experience a kind of emotional blockage, feeling undeserving of a warm, inviting space.
“It comes down to self-worth, asking, what kind of person is worthy enough to have a house?”
While many people furnish their homes with practical items like televisions and silverware, they may struggle to incorporate anything that reflects their personal taste.
“In order to have preferences, you have to be someone,” he said.
“If you were never given the space to observe and honor your preferences, you don’t have access to your sense of self, and as a consequence, when you do something like decorate a house, your first thought is always ‘I don’t know,’” added Barbieri, who co-hosts the podcast 2 Dudes Talkin’ Therapy.
Barbieri explained that people navigating complex trauma — including prolonged exposure to neglect or abuse — may have lost, or never fully developed, a solid sense of self or an understanding of their own desires.
“It’s too vulnerable to know what you want because when you were a child, knowing what you wanted might have been dangerous,” he explains, noting that as adults, these same people may choose not to obey or explore their wants, whether it’s a lighting fixture or a romantic partner, out of fear of judgment, both external and internal.
“The choices you make are going to be judged, and when it’s your house, you don’t want that exposure to judgment to find its way in,” he said.
Other experts argue that survivors struggle with decorating because the act itself is a commitment, which can feel dangerous to a nervous system that has learned that safety is temporary.
Barbieri added that many people don’t decorate because they fear that if they let their house truly reflect them, they may not like what they see.
“A lot of self-acceptance and self-love has to happen for a person to be willing to look at that reflection,” he said.
To that end, Barbieri explained that dismissing home decorating as inconsequential is a major misstep.
“Not everyone’s materialistic just because they care about decorating,” he said.
“They’re tapping into expressing a part of themselves that maybe the person who’s criticizing them can’t.”
While he resists pathologizing people based on home interiors, Barbieri acknowledged that some generalizations track.
“I think someone with ADHD, unless they are on top of it, is probably going to have a cluttered space. For people with ADHD, it’s a big struggle to try and control the chaos, and so often that’s reflected in their environment.”
And that clutter has consequences; it’s been linked to elevated levels of cortisol and can lead to feelings of anxiety and guilt.
Conversely, Barbieri said people who lean hard into a minimalist aesthetic are “trying very hard to regulate themselves,” cueing the collective trauma response that is “Millennial gray” and “sad beige.”
Neutral colors be damned, Barbieri believes that at its highest octave, interior design can be absolutely curative.
“It’s always healing to affirm something inside of you in your external world. It’s an opportunity in adulthood to get to know the parts of yourself you didn’t realize were there.”
He urges people who struggle with decor to begin with a simple set of questions.
“Ask yourself, what do I like? What colors do I like? Am I more mid-century? Do I want more whimsy? The second you start asking these questions is the second your sense of self starts to reveal itself to you.”
Barbieri says this self-inquiry can create a revolutionary kind of momentum.
“If you’ve never asked any of these questions, it could very quickly go from do I like the duvet I have to do I like my partner? That’s a scary question; if you’ve never asked it, it can set off a chain reaction that eventually leads to a larger change.”
In this way, the throw pillow is a portal to possibility, folks.
“On one level, the question of what color the area rug is going to be feels so trivial, but that’s a foot in the door of listening to your authentic self.”